-
Why these questions, and why me
-
Q1. How do I order from the Kennametal catalogue without getting lost in it?
-
Q2. Is Kennametal actually worth the premium over cheaper alternatives?
-
Q3. Laser tube cutting — what's the real difference between Lake Elmo and Albany?
-
Q4. So — what is the best 3D printer for a shop like ours?
-
Q5. What's the worst mistake you've made on a purchase like this?
-
Q6. Any other patterns worth knowing?
Why these questions, and why me
I'm the office administrator for a 65-person fabrication and machining shop. I manage about $440K in annual spend across nine vendors — cutting tools, laser-cut tube services, and the odd capital item, most recently a 3D printer. I report to both the operations manager and the finance lead, which means I'm the person who has to explain why the invoice doesn't match the quote.
These are the questions I keep getting in email threads, so here they are with my honest answers. I'll be upfront: I'm not a machinist or a laser engineer. What I can speak to is what happens on the purchasing side — lead times, invoicing, TCO, and the little things that blow up the budget.
Q1. How do I order from the Kennametal catalogue without getting lost in it?
Here's what took me a few years to appreciate: the Kennametal catalogue is detailed by design, and that's actually the point. Every insert, end mill, and boring bar entry lists ISO material grades, coating type, and chipbreaker geometry. Compare that to cheaper brands where the catalogue entry is basically "carbide insert, 3/8 inch" and nothing else.
For a buyer like me, that level of detail is a risk reducer, not a nuisance. When I place an order, I can confirm the exact grade and chipbreaker with the shop before it ships. If we order by a generic spec and the insert doesn't match the job, that's a return, a re-order, and usually a day of lost cycle time. The Kennametal catalogue gives me enough on the page that I don't have to guess.
If I remember correctly, the catalogue also flags which items are stocked vs. built-to-order — but don't quote me on that; that's worth verifying with your rep because it can change.
Q2. Is Kennametal actually worth the premium over cheaper alternatives?
Honestly, not always. It depends on the job.
I switched to total-cost thinking about three years ago, and it's been the single most useful shift in how I evaluate any quote. Unit price is the visible part. The invisible part is tool life, index time, scrap risk, and the downtime cost of a run stopping because a cheap insert chipped.
Concrete example. A colleague tried a knock-off end mill that was roughly 40% cheaper per piece. Two things happened: it wore out at about 2.5× the rate, and it produced two scrapped stainless parts on a customer order. The rework ate the savings for about three months. That's not a universal truth — for short runs, soft materials, or non-critical features, the cheaper option is often fine. But where the customer spec is tight, I lean toward the brand.
That's a procurement judgment, not an engineering judgment. If your shop engineer wants to run the cheaper tool on a specific job, trust their call — they see the chips, I see the invoices.
Q3. Laser tube cutting — what's the real difference between Lake Elmo and Albany?
Our engineering team has used both, and honestly the difference is less about capability than logistics.
Lake Elmo serves the Twin Cities region — aerospace and medical device shops mostly — and runs tight lead times because that regional customer base expects it. Albany serves the Northeast and tends to run a bit more flexible on scheduling, which sometimes means a better slot if you're not in a rush.
From where I sit, the deciding factor is almost always freight plus time-to-dock. If we're in the Twin Cities metro, a Lake Elmo pickup can save two or three days versus shipping from Albany. But if the Lake Elmo quote excludes deburring and the Albany quote includes it, the all-in cost flips fast. I now ask for a line-item breakdown on both before comparing — a flat per-part number isn't a comparison, it's a conversation starter.
Standard reference if you're shipping or storing laser-processed parts: ANSI Z136.1 governs laser safety requirements in the US. Your shop's safety officer will know whether you need the cutting vendor to certify anything on your behalf.
Q4. So — what is the best 3D printer for a shop like ours?
This is where I have to draw a boundary. I'm not a manufacturing engineer, and "best" for a 3D printer really means "best fit for your intended part geometry, material, and tolerance." I can't speak to that.
What I can say is how I evaluate the purchase from a procurement angle. Two things drive the decision:
- What's the printer for? If it's jigs, fixtures, and prototypes, a desktop FDM machine does the job. If it's end-use plastic parts at any real volume, dimensional stability and material certification come into play and the whole cost model changes.
- What's the total cost after year one? The hardware is the easy line item. Filament or resin cost per functional part, calibration downtime, and the labor to finish a print are the numbers nobody puts on the quote sheet.
For terminology and standards, ISO/ASTM 52900 is the reference for additive manufacturing — useful if you need to write a spec or a PO that will hold up with finance. For the actual machine recommendation, get your shop engineer in the room before you sign anything.
Q5. What's the worst mistake you've made on a purchase like this?
Communication. The first one that comes to mind: I said "ASAP" on a tube-cutting order. My supplier heard "in the next scheduled run." The parts arrived about two weeks later than I needed them for a customer inspection. Nothing lost, but I looked bad to the ops manager, and I don't like doing that.
Since then, I don't write "ASAP" anymore. I write a specific date — "Friday, March 14th, 2025" — and then I confirm in writing that my date is their delivery date. That one habit has saved more headaches than any pricing negotiation I've ever run.
Q6. Any other patterns worth knowing?
One more. The third time a vendor invoice came in ten or twelve percent over the quote because of "setup fees" or "standard packaging," I finally built a simple one-page quote checklist — landing cost, lead time, deburring or finishing included, freight terms, payment terms. I should have done it after the first time, but three was enough to make it stick.
One rule I'll pass on: before you compare any two prices, ask "what's included in this number?" Most of the time, the cheaper quote is cheaper because the vendor quietly pulled something out — a finish step, an inspection report, standard freight. Put every add-on back in, and the comparison starts to actually mean something.
Prices and lead-time assumptions above reflect my notes through Q1 2025. Tooling and cutting-service pricing moves with carbide and steel indices — verify current rates before you build them into a budget.